Preview
David H Payne

David H Payne
Payne Insurance Agency, Inc
232 North Main Street
Rushville, IN 46173
888-932-3966
Send an email

Monday - Friday: 8:30am to 5:00pm
Sat: 8:30am to 12:00pm
Closed Sundays and Holidays

Payne Insurance Agency has been helping families and businesses in Indiana with all of their insurance needs for over 50 years.

Health Plan Options:


Health Access Limited-Benefit Plans
  • Affordable – Choose a plan that meets your financial and lifestyle needs.
  • Everyday Needs – Cover the important things like doctor office visits, prescriptions, preventative care and immunizations.
  • Value – You have first-dollar benefits, which means your plan pays before you do! PLUS you will receive discounts with our network and health care partnerships
  • Flexible: Keep your own doctor, choose individual or family coverage and take advantage of additional coverage options.
  • Quick and Easy to Qualify
 Get a quote now or APPLY ONLINE!


Individual & Family Health Plans Health insurance for individuals and families
  • Extensive doctor and hospital networks provide significant savings
  • Health Savings Accounts offer tax benefits on your health care spending
  • Wide range of plans and benefit options tailored to your needs
 Get a quote now or APPLY ONLINE!


Short Term Medical Insurance Temporary health insurance for 30-360 days (varies by state)
  • Coverage as early as the next day
  • Freedom to choose any doctor or hospital
  • Prescription drug coverage for extra peace of mind
  • 100% coinsurance option takes the guesswork out of what you owe
  • Lifetime benefits up to $2 million provide added security
  • Willing to limit benefits for a lower premium? Quote for the HealthSaver® plan.
 Get a quote now or APPLY ONLINE!


Student Health Insurance Individual Health insurance for college students
  • Easy to apply -- just a few questions - and coverage can start as quick as the next day
  • Freedom to choose any doctor or hospital
  • Year-round coverage that's not dependent on student status and that moves with students -- not limited by location
  • Coverage for services students are most likely to use like doctor visits, prescriptions and preventive care
  • Two affordably priced plans
 Get a quote now or APPLY ONLINE!

About Us

Payne Insurance Agency, Inc. provides families and businesses in Indiana with quality insurance products, placed with ethical, financially sound insurance carriers, and to provide loyal, dependable representation to both entities. Our owners and employees are challenged to accomplish all this with skilled management, experience, teamwork and constant improvement in knowledge and skills. With the final goal of customer / insurance company satisfaction, monetary rewards and pride in a job well done for agency personnel.